Pages

Wednesday, June 18, 2014

Soviet Union Meeting 6/17/14 Putin Hurley Present

It is like Belfast Planning Board Member said about City plans for residents- "Soviet Union". City Council is acting like they didn't know Seaview Terrace is being pulled from the group of residential zoning neighborhoods and into a new zone- Healthcare and Housing. The City Planner, Wayne Marshall puts in writing that the goal is due away with single family housing, replacing it with professional offices. He is not a well man. Calculating, no empathy, thinks he has every right to destroy family after family with illegal planning. Destroying private property, denying it, locking up the documents. He came on in 1999, and he is in for the kill of in-town Belfast non-worthies, implicating a web of supporters through greed- City Manager, City Council, City Attorney, committee's, downtown business organizations... Misspending off the charts and unreported for the wants, enormous cost for this 10 year Comprehensive Plan, attorneys, consults, Wayne calculating each loophole to sneak in the death of single family, low- middle income homes. Many neighborhoods deteriorating because they do not use tax dollars for resident infrastructure. The lengths they go to deny their Soviet Union ways, many residents are conditioned to accept it or are in denial themselves. Or they had to do some illegal draining because there are no sewers, so they are in fear. Volumes are on my other blogs. For 4 years I have uncovered so much filth as I try to save my home.

All of the Wall in City Hall have known the details of this plan for years. Three years ago, after the City Tax Assessor, Bob Whiteley toured the paths of forced flooding destruction to my neighborhood, he was shocked and tried to cover, but he couldn't. It is so bad. He said the plans coming down the pike are shattering for residents. That is this Comprehensive Plan. Seaview Terrace is the first kill, but it will ooze in, forcing residents into bankruptcy if they attempt legal action when they are the chopping block next.

I have only read the overview, the actual ordinance proposals just went public within in the past 2 days. Public Hearing is July 2, big holiday week, Wayne Marshall City Planner, calculating again. Public Hearings are fluff, but not this time. My neighbors are on it. I made them aware weeks ago, we were getting rezoned. We hit some City Council meetings to be heard, prior to the fluff. To make sure other residents and neighborhoods are on their proposed changes. Not much time to research. Calculated again.

I found gold online. Maine State Comprehensive Plan procedures. It begins at page 260-easy to read- only about 5 pages-I gave relevant sections below proving Belfast City Hall broke the law procedure.


Note the red section, clearly stating that Contract Zoning is an art word. In the meeting, City Planner Wayne Marshall and City Council try to confuse. Stating this the law I am citing is Contract Zoning- has nothing to do with rezoning our neighborhood. In the face of facts and documents, they flat out lie, again trying to make me look stupid. Giving the illusion that I have been stupid for 4 years with the corruption I have exposed with proof.

The City Attorney sat in for this whole meeting. He was there because he knew Seaview Terrace would be speaking at open to the public. City Council refused to give us an agenda, calculating to control as much open discussion as possible. Code and Zoning, Todd Rosenburg was in the back as well. Neither were on the agenda, neither spoke during the meeting. An executive session was scheduled for after. Clearly. Seaview Terrace is the session.  My neighbors poked holes in the their greedy plan, they were excellent. I was dismissed, but no matter. The troops have arrived.
http://mainelaw.maine.edu/academics/maine-law-review/pdf/vol24_2/vol24_me_l_rev_263.pdf

Maine Law Comprehensive Plan Contract Zoning: A Flexible Technique for Protecting Maine Municipalities
Since the constitutionality of comprehensive zoning plans was upheld
by the 1926 United States Supreme Court decision in Euclid v. Ambler
Realty,1 municipal zoning has become an acceptable, indeed a necessary,
fact of life. Maine, as well as most states, has enacted zoning enabling
legislation 2 pursuant to which many Maine municipalities have adopted
zoning ordinances3. The standard zoning approach which has evolved
since Euclid has been based largely on the concept of uniform gridiron
districts which conform to a legislatively preconceived comprehensive
plan intended to assist municipalities in maintaining an orderly growth.'
These comprehensive plans, however, frequently have become a planning
burden because they discourage land uses which were not anticipated
either at the time the original plans were written or when the plans were
updated.5 As a result, the traditional zoning approach is often incapable
of meeting the demands of a growing society with its rapid technological,
environmental, and cultural changes. Contract zoning, properly utilized
as a complementary planning mechanism, can enable a municipality to
adapt quickly and effectively to such unanticipated demands.
It should be understood at the outset that the phrase "contract zoning"
is simply a convenient term of art. It has no legal significance in and of
itself but merely refers to a reclassification of a land use in which the
landowner agrees, prior to a zoning amendment, to perform conditions
not imposed on others in the same zoning classification. ...
1. First Step-  Pg 263 "LANDOWNER AGREES PRIOR TO A ZONING AMENDMENT, TO PERFORM CONDITIONS NOT IMPOSED ON OTHERS IN THE SAME ZONING CLASSIFICATION.”

Belfast City Hall has violated the first step- no one came to talk to Seaview Terrace landowners to get our agreement to go forward with the new zone- R3- Healthcare and Housing. After that, than the Belfast Planning Board must be persuaded to approve the PROPOSED ordinance changes. After that it goes out to Public Hearing.

In this meeting, City Planner Wayne Marshall attempts to cover up this violation, by claiming letters went out in 2009? This guy is stupid. NO LANDOWNERS AGREED PERIOD. NONE WERE CONTACTED. SOME IN RESIDENCE FOR OVER 20 YEARS. One neighbor states she has been here 12 years, and didn't know anything about this till last month. When I put out a new sign stating NO R3 Zoning 4 Us. I had caught wind of it when City Planner, Wayne Marshall lightly mentioned it in a meeting.

2. Second Step Pg 267-However, even if a municipality is WILLING AND ABLE TO FINANCE SUCH A PROFESSIONAL STAFF, the desired flexibility is still not assured. A PLANNING BOARD, WHICH IN MAINE IS GENERALLY COMPRISED OF LAYMAN, MUST UNDERSTAND, BE PERSUADED AND APPROVE ANY PROPOSED CHANGES IN THE PLAN. The procedure is further complicated and delayed by the statutory requirement that “that the public shall be given and ADEQUATE opportunity to be heard.”

 I have requested a freedom of information for all this information used to "persuade" and the members recorded votes and names. That was on 6/5/14, to City Manager- Joe Slocum. He has yet to fill that request, it was due on 6/13/14.) They are attempting to manipulate the request. Clearly, this second step has been corrupted. I third requested it today, 6/18/14.

Link to 6/17/14 Belfast City Council Meeting. Click on #6 and #11 Seaview Terrace residents protest rezoning. Calculating to dismiss the violations, City Planner Wayne Marshall attempts to confuse with a rant about Contract Rezoning, stating that is not relevant to Seaview Terrace. See the red mad man. It is absolutely what you are proposing to do to Seaview Terrace. Others in our zoning classification are proposed to go together to R1.  Council Roger Lee laughing and smirking at me for citing Maine Law in #11. See the red mad man.

My neighbor speak the OVERTONE of HEAVY government coming down on us without grounds. She continues. The current zoning allows for a Dr.'s office on Seaview Terrace. Not one has opted on this dead end, rapidly deteriorating from force flooding, 20 ft wide street. Natural selection. Seaview Terrace was never a natural selection. Forcing a drive to this neighborhood with this new R3 zoning is corruption. The hidden perks and loopholes combined with the strong language- even some one as "stupid" as me can see the plan. A new resident is immediately aware of the Wall and tactics. He speaks strong and is another savior of Seaview Terrace. He is a Dr. of language, life long journalist. He has skimmed some of the insane ordinances that were JUST made public.

It must be painful for him to read my poor writing skills. Formal education was not in my reach. I graduated high school in 1978. September 1978, into Midas Muffler International, shipping clerk in a warehouse full of men and truckers. Seventeen and a blooming body that would taint my rights and goals. I began night school immediately, worked my way up and out into a great job in less than 3 years. I was soaring, got up to 36 credits before family illness and their addictions would take me down. Never to reach that plateau again. It became survival.

Moving here in 2010 was dangerous and costly. I did it alone and against the odds, huge dangerous odds. Never having a chance to heal, right into the fight for my life, again, by the government. Kick the can. I am the can. This is  what City Hall and the real estate agents have done to me. Jeopardizing all the safety and stability crucial to the lives of my children and myself.. I write this, because through all these public speakings, emails protests,  I have had to maintain courage, avoid their baiting and recover immediately when I was forced into another deception.

They are calculating ruthless. Clear to see in this meeting, as always treating me like shit. Giving passage for many others to do the same. Social stoning without stones. Pitting neighbors against me. But, not all.

As I have for 3 years, protesting, investigating, questioning and getting the life sucked out of me for doing so. White collar threatening of my life. Documented. Two recent "conversations" initiated with intent by the Belfast Police Department. The last with the Chief of Police, Mike McFadden and Officer Ward as I allowed them into my home to investigate my stability. When I didn't crack, they resorted to shaming me as a mother. Basically telling me, for the 2nd time, that fighting to save my home is embarrassing my young adult children. They as parents, would not do that. Interview done. I told the Chief I was offended and my family was off limits from here on in.

Frightening to think now, how bad that could have went. City Hall has been baiting to break me since 2011. Way back then,  City Council called me in as a threat to the Chief of Police, Mike McFadden. The "first" conversation in his office, certainly recorded with cause to do a full back ground check. At the end, the Chief would state that I was the high lite of his day. Ditto. I was able to piece together that his brother in law is the cable guy, Tom from Time Warner Cable that had been in my home several times already. Neither one had shared  with me that they were family. I gave Tom an earful each time he came here. Full access to my computer. It was when Tom was testing it, he brought up a you tube video of a ride on, no brakes lawn mower restoration. I love that stuff. He told me his brother in law had a passion for restoring these. In my first interview with the Chief, he revealed that he did lawn mower restorations. I blurted out- Hey, you're the brother in law of the cable guy, I just saw you video a few weeks ago. The Chief was alarmed that I connected them. Now, I am alarmed.

City Council was frightened by me. Right. A beat up, broke Mom who crawled here to begin again, under the radar, in peace and new hope. One giant step away from death's door. Only, the dragged me into the fire pit of hell, a whole pack of them, the spring of 2011 when all their force came crashing through my yard in wild rapids for days on end... no stream, nothing ever disclosed. The secret hell of inverse condemnation, made by City Hall, the public conditioned clueless.

http://belfastme.swagit.com/play/06172014-1440/#3

It should be understood at the outset that the phrase "contract zoning"
is simply a convenient term of art. It has no legal significance in and of
itself but merely refers to a reclassification of a land use in which the
landowner agrees, prior to a zoning amendment, to perform conditions
not imposed on others in the same zoning classification. ...

Tuesday, June 10, 2014

Put Up Your Dukes, Let's Get Down To It....

6/14/14 Holy Cow! Councilor Mike Hurley just sent ANOTHER response to the ongoing email saga below. He has cracked, threatening with 2 choices- lose our residential homes to an office complex or final destruction via the enormous volumes of illegal forced run off flooding to the private property, flood plain, flood zone, 12 homes on Seaview Terrace aka "the new Grand Canyon". New Movie at the Colonial Theater (owned by Mike Hurley) "PUTIN" on the Happy Video...

Belfast Planning Board member, Wayne Corey compared the intent of the plan to the Soviet Union. HELLO, HELLO- IS ANYBODY OUT THERE??? City Hall is playing you, right into the theater of illusion. Be Happy, Be Happy, I said so. You will be rewarded, you will feel happy. Don't look at the ones who are suffering. Keep dancing for me. (My post in the local paper, Village Soup, Republican Journal)

From the Belfast Coalitions site:
The Belfast Maine We Are Happy music video will premiere at The Colonial Theatre this Friday, June 13th 3:30.  Everyone is invited to see the video and the long version on the big screen for free at The Colonial Theatre in downtown Belfast.  We will introduce the videos and do a short Q and A and seat as many people as possible showing the films from 3:30 until 5:00.  That same evening and Saturday and Sunday the films will show on BEL-TV channel 2 and following the weekend the films will go live on Youtube.com.  Thanks to all the volunteers, dancers, and sponsors who are helping Our Town Belfast to show the world that WE ARE HAPPY!
From: Mike Hurley (mike@pilut.com) This sender is in your contact list.
Sent:Sat 6/14/14 11:39 AM
To:'LAURIE ALLEN' (laurieallen55@msn.com); citymanager@cityofbelfast.org; ward1councilor@cityofbelfast.org; ward2councilor@cityofbelfast.org; ward3councilor@cityofbelfast.org; ward4councilor@cityofbelfast.org; ward5councilor@cityofbelfast.org; mayor@cityofbelfast.org; 
Which one is it? An all-encompassing office complex or the new Grand Canyon?

6/13/14- See email requesting specific public information, manipulated by Joe Slocum, Belfast City Manager to buy time and deny. Councilor Mike Hurley bends and breaks the law for his visions. I Believe The Law. I cite Maine State Law procedure specific to Comprehensive Plans. Belfast City Manager, Planning and Council are clearly not following procedure. Written to protect residents from calculating, greedy officials. Surely implicated from City Planner Wayne Marshall's corrupt reign since approximately 1999. Locking up the paper trail, destroying innocent life after innocent life.















I'm bringing up the rear- house flag high in one hand- camcorder in the other- Marine Corp Horsey steps up to escort me. Simple and true, this Belfast I love.





6/13 14-  Belfast City Manager, Joe Slocum must respond- either rescind illegal rezoning residential Seaview Terrace to Healthcare and Housing or illegally continue and abuse residents. This time- I got to the corruption early- easy lawsuit. Sick Officials.

Below was sent today @ 12 :37, first I'll post Councilor Mike Hurley's Immediate Insult. BTW- he is airing his brainwashing Happy Belfast video in his theater today. Super Sick.
______________________________________________________________________________
Mike Hurley (mike@pilut.com
Fri 6/13/14 12:52 PM
'LAURIE ALLEN' (laurieallen55@msn.com

What would be helpful would be if you were capable of believing the basic information.

____________________________________________________________________________
On Fri, Jun 13, 2014 at 12:37 PM, LAURIE ALLEN <laurieallen55@msn.com> wrote:

City Manager Joe Slocum, Belfast City Council and Mayor,

Please respond today per my FOAA 6/6/14 and agenda requested 6/3/14.

1. Has  Seaview Terrace been approved for rezoning to R1 and included into the R1 public hearings? If not, please respond to #2 and #3.  (Advise to all recipients on this email)

2a. Respond via email today- Members of the Belfast Planning Board approving amendment to rezone residential Seaview Terrace to R3- Healthcare and Housing. (Advise to all recipients on this email) 

 b. All the information provided to "persuade" the Belfast Planning Board to approve the proposed change to rezone Seaview Terrace to R3, Healthcare and Housing. The residential zone is the most stringent zone to protect residents.
 (Advise to all recipients on this email)

3. Confirm  6/17/14 City Council Meeting agenda for discussion of validity to rezone residential Seaview Terrace to R3- Healthcare and Housing per 6/3 open to the public request at Council Meeting. (Advise to all recipients on this email) 

It is VERY difficult to obtain basic information. It would be helpful to be helpful rather than look for loopholes to deny. 

City Manager, Joe Slocum is:

>>>Misleading the public in procedures (see Maine State Law below landowners must agree to change, Planning Board approval, then public hearings)

Maine Law Comprehensive Plan Contract Zoning: A Flexible Technique for Protecting Maine Municipalities
http://mainelaw.maine.edu/academics/maine-law-review/pdf/vol24_2/vol24_me_l_rev_263.pdf

  Pg 263 "LANDOWNER AGREES PRIOR TO A ZONING AMENDMENT, TO PERFORM CONDITIONS NOT IMPOSED ON OTHERS IN THE SAME ZONING CLASSIFICATION.”

Pg. 267 "A PLANNING BOARD, WHICH IN MAINE IS GENERALLY COMPRISED OF LAYMAN, MUST UNDERSTAND, BE PERSUADED AND APPROVE ANY PROPOSED CHANGES IN THE PLAN. The procedure is further complicated and delayed by the statutory requirement that “that the public shall be given and ADEQUATE opportunity to be heard.”  

>>>Delaying FOAA illegally and charging unreasonably for public information (see below in red. Using Wayne Marshall's absence and information contributes to all residents.)

The Freedom of Access Act (FOAA) is a state statute that is intended to open the government of Maine by guaranteeing access to the "public records" and "public proceedings" of state and local government bodies and agencies.

Can an agency or official delay responding if my request was not directed to the agency public access officer?

No. An agency that receives a request to inspect or copy a public record must acknowledge and respond regardless of whether the request was directed to the public access officer. The unavailability of a public access officer may not be reason for a delay1 M.R.S. § 413(3)

The agency or official may, but is not required to, waive part or all of the total fee if the requester is indigent, or if the agency or official considers release of the public record to be in the public interest because it is likely to contribute significantly to public understanding of the operations or activities of government and is not primarily in the commercial interest of the requester1 M.R.S. § 408-A(11)

Sincerely,
Laurie Allen
______________________________________________________________________________
From: Mike Hurley (mike@pilut.com) This sender is in your contact list.
Sent:Fri 6/13/14 12:52 PM
To:'LAURIE ALLEN' (laurieallen55@msn.com)

What would be helpful would be if you were capable of believing the basic information.
 _____________________________________________________________________________
Date: Fri, 13 Jun 2014 17:02:44 -0400
Subject: Re: FOAA 6/6/14
From: citymanager@cityofbelfast.org
To: laurieallen55@msn.com


Ms Allen,
 My email of June 9th said I would try to get you a response within 5 business days of June 11. The Zoning applicable to your street has not changed. There are no findings of fact. We are trying to upload on the Website  #1 The Comprehensive Planning Committee's recommendations on land use in Belfast, the present regulations for these districts  and the various changes the Planning Board is recommending. The exact boundary descriptions will follow. Please note that the Uses and Dimensional proposals should all be on line shortly. We are trying to get them on as I write this.
Sincerely

 Joe Slocum
________________________________________________________________________________________
From: LAURIE ALLEN [mailto:laurieallen55@msn.com]
Sent: Friday, June 13, 2014 6:43 PM
To: citymanager@cityofbelfast.org; ward1councilor@cityofbelfast.org; ward2councilor@cityofbelfast.org; ward3councilor@cityofbelfast.org; ward4councilor@cityofbelfast.org; ward5councilor@cityofbelfast.org; mayor@cityofbelfast.org; 

City Manager Joe Slocum, City Council and Mayor,

Joe Slocum's response is not clear and is wasting valuable time to resolve ethically and sensibly. Please do not manipulate my request again. The procedure is Maine State Law. Joe Slocum City Manager is not following State Law procedure written to protect residents rights. Council put an open to the public speaker right on that night's agenda at the 6/3/14 City Council Meeting. I spoke right before that business man and asked to be put on the agenda that night since Seaview Terrace residents were present. Denied. I gave the option for an agenda on 6/17/14 as well. Apparently denied again, as I see in the agenda for 6/17/14 posted today. You are denying the residents of Seaview Terrace due process. Forcing us into rezoning hearings with healthcare that are not appropriate through illegal procedures. 

I see Wayne Marshall is on the agenda to discuss zoning. Certainly it would make sense to allow Seaview Terrace residents their rights to be heard by City Council and the public with an agenda for discussion. These difficult restrictions imposed on residents rights and public information, is as Planning Board Member, Wayne Corey stated similar to tactics of the "Soviet Union". I do not believe Wayne Corey would have approved this proposed rezoning of Seaview Terrace.   

Please answer specifically in language used in 1, 2a,  2b and 3, I repeated the exact request below. Originally requested 6/6/14 (tweaking"findings of fact" to "all information provided to 'persuade' the Belfast Planning Board to approve the proposed change from residential Seaview Terrace to Healthcare & Housing Seaview Terrace")

1. Has  Seaview Terrace been approved for rezoning to R1 and included into the R1 public hearings? If not, please respond to #2 and #3.  (Advise to all recipients on this email)

2a. Respond via email today- Members of the Belfast Planning Board approving amendment to rezone residential Seaview Terrace to R3- Healthcare and Housing. (Advise to all recipients on this email) 

 b. All the information provided to "persuade" the Belfast Planning Board to approve the proposed change to rezone Seaview Terrace to R3, Healthcare and Housing. The residential zone is the most stringent zone to protect residents.
 (Advise to all recipients on this email)

3. Confirm  6/17/14 City Council Meeting agenda for discussion of validity to rezone residential Seaview Terrace to R3- Healthcare and Housing per 6/3 open to the public request at Council Meeting. (Advise to all recipients on this email) (advise to all recipients on this email)

Sincerely

Laurie Allen
_______________________________________________________________________________
From: Mike Hurley (mike@pilut.com) This sender is in your contact list.
Sent:Sat 6/14/14 11:39 AM
To:'LAURIE ALLEN' (laurieallen55@msn.com); citymanager@cityofbelfast.org; ward1councilor@cityofbelfast.org; ward2councilor@cityofbelfast.org; ward3councilor@cityofbelfast.org; ward4councilor@cityofbelfast.org; ward5councilor@cityofbelfast.org; mayor@cityofbelfast.org; charlesbeck7@gmail.com; rosicostello@gmail.com

Which one is it? An all-encompassing office complex or the new Grand Canyon?

__________________________________________________________________________________________

5/28/14  
R3 Zoning would allow healthcare facilities into our small 12 family residential neighborhood. Next door neighbor could be a Meth. Clinic, Drug Rehab. Mental Health... Provisions won't mean a thing, although Belfast City Planner will attempt to Snow(den) us.  Once the land use is in place for healthcare, approvals will fly. Belfast City Hall uses a flexible rule to screw the resident and breaks the law again and again.

My neighbor, Erin,who moved here from Alaska, a few months after me in 2010, drove past me this morning when I was protesting in the video above(sorry- can't get it uploaded- will keep trying), I was smiling and waving good morning to all the cars passing by. Including the Belfast Public Works Director, Bob Richards, one of the club. Bob did not wave back. Another man, over 50, in a new model, rust? burgundy, I think, Maine plates, SUV gave me the finger. And unbelievably so did Erin. Clearly City Hall has tainted her, we used to be friendly. agreeing with the City destruction and corruption to our neighborhood.  I hired her several times to photograph the erosion and my daughter's prom pictures. Recently, The Belfast Police Department hired her to take department photo's...hello.

City Hall is infamous for pitting neighbors against each other- two other neighbors became implicated in their web and came to public, televised, City Council meetings and spoke against me. Nice. Other's attack me on posts in the local papers. My children went and go to school here. The children I have gone above and beyond to protect and relocate. Nothing and no one is off limits to intimidate me. No Russia for me, much more personal, in my home, with children, single, no family, no protection, no support, no money, no attorneys... Just me, truth all the way, my only fear is harm to my children and pets. Hit me with your best shot, fire away..


Monday, June 9, 2014

Belfast Planning board divided on splitting small properties, big houses - PenBay Pilot

Belfast Planning board divided on splitting small properties, big houses - PenBay Pilot

"Corey and Minor both felt that current property owners, who had made purchases and subsequent investments based on existing zoning, would be hurt if the rules were changed. Corey said he was not entirely opposed to the idea, but it didn’t sit right with his sense of how a free market system should work. Here he mentioned the Soviet Union.
“It’s not up to us to make people richer or poorer,” he said".
________________________________________________________________________________

Wayne Corey, an ethical Planning Board Member insinuating Soviet Union tactics in this Comprehensive Plan which certainly pointing to  "Pave paradise and put in a parking lot" by rezoning the 12 home, single family residential zoned, dead end street of Seaview Terrace to Healthcare and Housing. Clear corruption at hand. The first would be the preliminary approval by the Planning Board and supporting findings of fact. Cough it up, City Manager Joe Slocum and City Planner Wayne Marshall. Email documents to Seaview Terrace residents, City Council and Mayor by Friday 6/13/14 and slate us on the City Council agenda 6/17/14 to review documented approvals publicly and ascertain that Seaview Terrace will be in to correct public hearings mere weeks away, and the public is clueless. Ordinances still being held by City Hall. When posted on website, be sure to make full legible  pages. Shrinking pages and pages onto 1 page into  Minnie Mouse font is a "Soviet Union" tactic and a disgrace. Clearly prohibiting the public for ease of crucial public information. C O R R U P T I O N !!

Below or above- not sure if I can rearrange is a second request email for Freedom of Information Public Documents for the Maine State Law Comprehensive Plans- cited and with link, Planning Board approval Findings to rezone our long established since development in 1967, 12 single family homes, zoned residential, dead end street, Seaview Terrace into Health Care and Housing. Clearly, City Hall is steamrolling to corruptly and intentionally violate our land, Joni Mitchell echoing through this "Soviet Union" plan...

They paved paradise 
And put up a parking lot 
With a pink hotel *, a boutique 
And a swinging hot spot 

Don't it always seem to go 
That you don't know what you've got 
Till it's gone 
They paved paradise 
And put up a parking lot

They took all the trees 
Put 'em in a tree museum * 
And they charged the people 
A dollar and a half just to see 'em 

Don't it always seem to go 
That you don't know what you've got 
Till it's gone 
They paved paradise 
And put up a parking lot

Hey farmer farmer 
Put away that DDT * now 
Give me spots on my apples 
But leave me the birds and the bees 
Please! 

Don't it always seem to go 
That you don't know what you've got 
Till it's gone 
They paved paradise 
And put up a parking lot

Late last night
I heard the screen door slam
And a big yellow taxi
Took away my old man

Don't it always seem to go
That you don't know what you've got
Till it's gone
They paved paradise
And put up a parking lot



They paved paradise
And put up a parking lot

BELFAST - Charges of social engineering and classism featured in a lively Planning Board workshop, Wednesday night. Also mentioned were Jane Jacobs’ “The Death and Life of Great American Cities” and the Soviet Union.
The hot topic? Whether to reduce the minimum lot size in a densely populated area inside the bypass from 10,000 to 7,500 square feet.
The question, along with several others considered on Wednesday, is part of a larger review of zoning ordinances intended to align property laws with goals set out in the 2009 comprehensive plan, an organic continuum of the city’s history, or some compromise between the two.
The larger revisions included a major expansion of the densely populated, in-town zoning district known as Residential 1. Changing the minimum lot size in the redrawn district would affect 51 properties. A larger number of lots in the district are currently either too small to be affected by the change or large enough that they are already eligible for subdivision.
The Planning Board mostly discussed this district on Wednesday, however similar changes would apply to the Residential 2 and Residential 3 districts.
Wayne Corey asked why Belfast, which has not seen a population increase in 20 years would change zoning to encourage subdivision of properties. Elizabeth Minor asked if the idea had come about in response to requests from property owners.
City Planner Wayne Marshall said the recommendations were based on ideas outlined in the comprehensive plan.
“If the goal is to encourage growth in growth areas,” he said, referring to zones with existing services, “This has a potential to to make that occur.”
Minor questioned the wisdom of changing the rules when there was no demand. Referring to Jane Jacobs’ treatise on urban planning, she cautioned against imposing academic planning schemes on a city where the zoning already works.
“The only thing I can think of is that someone read somewhere that this was a good idea,” she said.
Corey said changing the current zoning amounted to giving some property owners “freebies” in the form of a now-sellable subdivision of their land.
Marshall countered the current minimum lot sizes came about in the same way. “What is [sacrosanct] about 10,000 square feet?” he said. Marshall added that many properties in the Residential 1 zone could already be subdivided under the existing rules. 
Minor interpreted the fact that they hadn’t as further indication that shrinking the minimum lot size was unnecessary. If the interest is not there, she argued, why change the rules?
Where Minor based her opposition partly on a lack of interest in subdividing among landowners, others looked at the issue from the perspective of a buyer.
Margot Carpenter said she had looked for vacant lots in town on several past occasions and had difficulty finding any.
Biff Atlass wagered that a market might emerge for the smaller lots in the future. The change, he said, might also allow longtime residents in danger of being priced out of their neighborhoods to stay by selling off a portion of their property.
Corey and Minor both felt that current property owners, who had made purchases and subsequent investments based on existing zoning, would be hurt if the rules were changed. Corey said he was not entirely opposed to the idea, but it didn’t sit right with his sense of how a free market system should work. Here he mentioned the Soviet Union.
“It’s not up to us to make people richer or poorer,” he said.
The history of the city was invoked in support of a variety of sometimes conflicting arguments. Marshall said the revised lot size could be seen as consistent with the numerous existing small lots that predate current zoning ordinances. Minor said the city had already been subject to inconsistent zoning imposed on neighborhoods.
Assistant City Planner Sadie Lloyd offered the example of Portland’s West End neighborhood, which had once comprised two houses but is now a thriving neighborhood.
Similarly, Belfast property lines once radiated from the bay and stretched a mile inland.
“Which history do you want to pick: when it was artificially too big, or artificially too small?” said board member Russell Barber.
Minor said the changes additionally overlooked the value of the city’s historic homes, to which Marshall hypothetically suggested an ordinance that prohibited subdividing lots of any size.
“It isn’t about square feet,” Minor said. “It’s contextual, and that’s what nobody gets.”
Chairman Paul Hamilton had a different word for it. It was “classist,” he said, to pick and choose which property owners get to do what they want. Minor disagreed.
In a straw poll, the majority of board members wanted more time to consider the proposal.
Another kind of subdivision
The topic of historic homes returned in a discussion of whether large homes should be eligible for conversion to multi-family dwellings.
The conversation came on the heels of a failed auction of the historic James P. White house (White House Inn). The landmark Greek Revival mansion had sold for $1.3 million in 2009 but didn’t get a single nod at a public sale Tuesday, despite an opening bid of $400,000.
Marshall showed the Planning Board a series of maps with the locations of dwellings ranging from 3,000 square feet to over 7,000 square feet and asked for opinions on whether any should be opened to alternate uses.
Minor noted that the larger properties were “almost without exception the most precious historical properties in Belfast.” She commended the care taken in converting the Johnson-Pratt House into Children’s Voice Preschool last year, but cautioned against the potentially slippery slope of broadly allowing alternate uses.
Several board members supported the idea of allowing conversion to condominiums, which they saw as more likely to be maintained than rental apartments.
The board also briefly considered a recommendation from Marshall that several specific properties inside the bypass be considered candidates for contract rezoning, which would allow deviations from zoning regulations subject to approval by the City Council.
Today, two properties in Belfast are governed by contract rezoning agreements: the Penobscot McCrum processing facility on Pierce Street and Front Street Shipyard.
Candidates from the new list included: Waterfall Arts (formerly Gov. Anderson School); the old hospital on High Street near Commercial Street; the former Peirce School/Belfast Academy of Music; the Alden House Inn and another property located diagonally across Church Street from the inn; the Harbor View House on Primrose Hill and others.
Marshall said he expects to present the Planning Board’s complete zoning recommendations for public review in April. 

Ethan Andrews can be reached at news@penbaypilot.com



Sunday, June 8, 2014

FOAA, Maine Law on Comp. Plan, & 6/17 Meeting Agenda Request!.

Date: Fri, 6 Jun 2014 12:00:26

Belfast City Manager Joe Slocum, City Council and Mayor,

I understand City Planner, Wayne Marshall is on vacation for some time. The Assistant Planner, Sadie Lloyd can certainly email the mandatory findings of fact requested below to me and my neighbors, Charles Beck and Rose Costello (emails are in the cc). This is a FOAA request, please email the documents within 5 days.

 The public document, mandatory Findings of Fact from the Belfast Planning Board Comprehensive Plan approving Seaview Terrace,  currently zoned  r2 zoned residential  single family neighborhood into a zone r3 housing and healthcare.

Sincerely,
Laurie Allen
17 Seaview Terrace
Belfast Maine 04915

Maine Law Comprehensive Plan Contract Zoning: A Flexible Technique for Protecting Maine Municipalities
http://mainelaw.maine.edu/academics/maine-law-review/pdf/vol24_2/vol24_me_l_rev_263.pdf
Pg 263- “It should be understood at the outset that the phrase “contract zoning” is simply a convenient term of art. It has no legal significance in and of itself but merely refers to a reclassification of a land use in which the LANDOWNER AGREES PRIOR TO A ZONING AMENDMENT, TO PERFORM CONDITIONS NOT IMPOSED ON OTHERS IN THE SAME ZONING CLASSIFICATION.”
Pg 265- “A comprehensive plan should encourage as well as REGULATE future development. If the CLASSIFICATION is not restrictive enough, an UNDESIRABLE proposal may be presented which cannot be denied by the municipality.”
Pg 266-67 “An obvious solution to the inflexibility of traditional zoning would be to consistently update the comprehensive plan of each municipality. Indeed, the desirability of such a continuous updating of comprehensive plans was impliedly recognized by the Maine legislature when it characterized the comprehensive plan as a “process” rather than as a static concept of municipality's future. To do so requires a professional staff of land planners and attorneys, who are continuously proposing modifications...”
“However, even if a municipality is WILLING AND ABLE TO FINANCE SUCH A PROFESSIONAL STAFF, the desired flexibility is still not assured. A PLANNING BOARD, WHICH IN MAINE IS GENERALLY COMPRISED OF LAYMAN, MUST UNDERSTAND, BE PERSUADED AND APPROVE ANY PROPOSED CHANGES IN THE PLAN. The procedure is further complicated and delayed by the statutory requirement that “that the public shall be given and ADEQUATE opportunity to be heard.”  
________________________________________________________________________________________
2nd request 
Sent:Tue 6/10/14 7:26 AM

City Manager Joe Slocum, Belfast City Council and Mayor,

See below this email(edit here on blog it is above-blue link) for supporting Maine Law. Using an excuse not to provide this public information until City Planner, Wayne Marshall returns. Assistant Planner, Sadie Lloyd can access the findings of fact with the planning boards approval within the 5 days FOAA which concludes Friday 6/13/14. With that information and the proposed ordinance changes to rezone Seaview Terrace to an R3, please place this on the agenda for discussion on Tuesday, 6/17/14. That is the last City Council meeting before the public hearings to rezone us on 7/2/14 and we have yet to receive public documents. 

It is IMPERATIVE that Seaview Terrace residents and Council review the Planning Boards documented approvals at the 6/17/14 City Council Meeting to validate legality for the proposal to rezone residential Seaview Terrace to R3- Healthcare and Housing. As I questioned the very same at open to the public in the 6/3/14 City Council Meeting as did Seaview Terrace neighbor, Charles Beck. I asked to be slated on the 6/17/14 agenda and am requesting confirmation that we will be on that agenda. If the findings do not support the proposed rezoning to R3, WE MUST BE INCLUDED IN TO THE PUBLIC HEARINGS FOR RESIDENTIALII REZONING INTO RESIDENTIAL1.  WE MUST BE ON THAT AGENDA TO PARTICIPATE IN THE APPROPRIATE PUBLIC HEARINGS.

Per Maine law cited below- the planning board had to approve these changes prior to going out to public hearing. City Manager Joe Slocum is delaying "adequate" public review through misleading information. Per his 6/9/14 email and past difficulty in receiving true documents, Joe Slocum is delaying any RESPONSE until 6/17/14- which could entail anything- such as- still looking, have to dig deep in our files, we have 4 thick files for you to sift through- good luck looking... City Manager, Joe Slocum, 6/9/14 email- "First the Planning Board will conduct Hearings and reflect on what they wish to recommend.  As you noted the City Planner is away until later this week and when he gets back I will follow up with you. You should expect a response from me  within 5 business days from Tune 11, 2014.

I will find out if there are any printed "findings"  at any stage of this Comprehensive Planning Process. If we have them and we can copy them then we will print them up for you at our standard photo copying rate for these request.

And more uncertainty from our City Council Rep, Mary Mortier:

5/27/14 Email from Seaview Terrace ward City Council and Real Estate Agent Mary Mortier:
Laurie,
The information is suppose to be available approx.June 11th for everyone inside the bypass to be able to review before the 3 public hearings. Printed copies will be available at City Hall & the Library. The city website will also have the information. The 1st. Public hearing is June 25th at Troy Howard for Res. 1.
The other 2 public hearings will be in July.
Mary Mortier